Reds Made Right Call Keeping Elly De La Cruz at Trade Deadline

There were teams that wanted Elly De La Cruz.

They called the Cincinnati Reds before the trade deadline and made their pitch for the 24-year-old shortstop, dangling what was reportedly a significant package of prospects and major league talent in an attempt to pry one of the game's most dynamic players away from a franchise that has spent years trying to build around him.

Cincinnati said no, and in doing so made the most important decision of its offseason without actually making a trade at all.

President of baseball operations Nick Krall did not hold back when asked about the direction of the franchise in the weeks following the deadline.

"I think we have a lot of talent on this club," Krall told MLB.com. "We have a really good young core still."

It reflects a front office that views De La Cruz as the centerpiece of whatever comes next in Cincinnati, even as the team's current record is disappointing.

The Reds sit at 61-68 and fifth in the NL Central, a far cry from the playoff contender some projected before the season, and the loss of Hunter Greene to a long-term injury has robbed the rotation of its most electric arm for the foreseeable future.

Trading De La Cruz in that context would have been an admission that the rebuild needs to start from scratch, and the Reds clearly do not believe that is the case.

De La Cruz has hit .257 with 20 home runs, 57 RBIs, and 22 stolen bases through 110 games this season, a stat line that represents a player still growing into his immense talent while already producing at an above-average level.

His combination of power and speed is nearly unmatched in the sport, and at 24 he still has multiple years of development ahead of him before he even enters what should be his prime.

The question Cincinnati has to answer is whether the supporting cast can catch up to De La Cruz quickly enough to capitalize on his best years.

The roster has genuine talent beyond the shortstop, but injuries and inconsistency have prevented the pieces from clicking simultaneously for any sustained stretch this season.

The Reds entered 2026 with real questions about their pitching depth, and those concerns proved to be right as the rotation struggled to find a reliable arm behind Greene and the bullpen weathered its own share of difficult stretches.

Keeping De La Cruz sends a message to the rest of the league and to the players already in the clubhouse that the Reds are building toward something rather than tearing it down.

Whether that faith pays off will depend on the front office's ability to surround their franchise player with the right pieces over the next few winters.

The talent is absolutely there, and a 24-year-old shortstop with 20-homer, 20-steal potential anchoring the middle of the lineup is not something teams give away easily, no matter how many blue-chip prospects are dangled in return.

The plan, at least, seems to be in place, and keeping De La Cruz was the first step in proving it.