By almost all measures, the Yankees’ decision to roll the dice this past offseason and trade for lefty starter Ryan Weathers has worked out like gangbusters. A talented arm that was once the seventh overall pick in the MLB Draft, Weathers had never thrown more than 95 big-league innings in a season despite debuting at the beginning of the decade. But the Yankees knew that with a rotation as deep as theirs, they could slot him in the back, allow him to flourish with lower expectations, and see what happened.
Although Weathers got off to an uneven start, once the Yankees got to work with him a little more, he turned into quite the steady, productive arm to have in the third or fourth spot of a rotation. On the season, he had a 3.56 ERA and 118 ERA+, and it was a 2.56 ERA from the beginning of July onward. In fact, in the past month, no qualified starter had a better ERA than Weathers’ 0.85. That was, of course, unsustainable, but spoke to how tough Weathers could be to hit at his best. And this was all coming from a guy who was firmly behind Cam Schlittler, Gerrit Cole, Max Fried, and Carlos Rodón on the rotation depth chart.
Weathers has been key to the part of the Yankees that has carried them since Aaron Judge went down at the end of May. Their offense has often been paltry, but the pitching has firmly held up. Now, it must be tested again because the injury bug has finally come at last for Weathers. He left his start on Saturday afternoon against the Blue Jays, mid-at-bat in the fourth. Weathers had allowed two runs on eight hits (granted, some weak contact) with three K’s in 3.1 innings. Out came the trainer …
View Link… and soon, out came the ominous report.
Ryan Weathers left the game with left forearm discomfort and will undergo imaging today.
— New York Yankees (@Yankees) August 22, 2026That is, in short, a damn shame. Imaging will reveal more, but the Yankees will no doubt play it carefully with Weathers.
In terms of immediate impact, the Yankees will need to fill Weathers’ spot in the rotation this coming week, particularly with a doubleheader on deck for next Saturday against Boston. Prospect Elmer Rodríguez has come up from Triple-A a few times in 2026 and could very well do so again. The doubleheader might create an opportunitity for spot starter Brendan Beck as well. Luis Gil is rehabbing as a reliever, so he would seem to be out of the equation.
Regardless, the Yankees are undoubtedly hoping these are all short-term solutions, as Fried—who just returned to the IL with another bone bruise in his left elbow—is already throwing in anticipation of a minimum IL stint. The soonest he could get back from the IL is the last series of August, though he’s probably more beholden to a throwing schedule than that. As far as Weathers goes, we’ll just have to see how serious the concern is on the elbow. If it’s Tommy John time, then see you in 2028. If it seems like he could still impact the team in 2026, perhaps it will be time to start using him in the bullpen in anticipation of a possible playoff role there (which was always possible given the rotation depth). That may be the best-case at this point.
Leave a Comment